---
title: "AWS security audit tools: Prowler vs Security Hub vs manual"
description: "AWS security audit tools compared: automated audit, manual audit, Prowler and AWS Security Hub. Scope, turnaround, deliverables and price, side by side."
url: https://audit.aws.silamir.com/en/aws-audit-comparison
lang: en
---

Comparison

# AWS security audit tools: automated, manual, Prowler or Security Hub?

Four ways to assess an AWS account, each answering a different need. This comparison helps you choose, and combine them.

## Four approaches, four uses

- **The Silamir [automated AWS audit](https://audit.aws.silamir.com/en/)**: a full review of one account, within the hour, with reports ready to present.
- **A manual audit**: a consulting engagement, run by consultants, which can go beyond the configuration (organisation, processes, interviews).
- **Prowler**: an open source security checking tool that your teams install and run themselves.
- **AWS Security Hub**: the AWS service that continuously assesses your accounts against the standards you enable.

## The comparison in one table

| Criterion | Silamir automated audit | Manual audit | Prowler | AWS Security Hub |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| **Nature** | One-off, automated audit service with AI analysis | Consulting engagement | Open source command-line tool | AWS service, enabled continuously |
| **Scope** | 10 domains: FSBP and CIS v5.0 security, FinOps, resilience, IAM, networking, web security… | Defined in the contract | Security and compliance, several hundred checks | Controls of the enabled standards (FSBP, CIS, PCI DSS, NIST…) |
| **Cost optimisation** | Yes: Savings Plans, rightsizing, unused resources, savings in euros | Depends on the engagement | No, security-focused | No |
| **Turnaround** | Usually 30–60 minutes | Several days to several weeks | Fast run, then internal analysis time | Continuous, once enabled |
| **Effort for your teams** | Deploy a read-only role, choose the regions | Interviews, access, reviews | Install, run, triage and interpret the results | Enable per account and region, process findings as they come |
| **Deliverables** | 10 Word and PDF reports, kill chains, remediation plan, P0/P1/P2 Excel, executive summary and board deck | Written report and debrief | Raw results (CSV, JSON, HTML) | Findings and scores in the console |
| **Prioritisation** | Cross-domain attack scenarios: an action that breaks three of them is P0 | Expert judgement | Severity per check | Severity per control |
| **Continuous monitoring** | No: a snapshot at a given date, to be run again | No | If you automate it | Yes |
| **Price** | 299 USD per audit, billed by AWS | On quotation | Free as open source; paid SaaS offering | Pay as you go, based on the checks evaluated |

## When to prefer a manual audit

- You need a view of organisation, processes and governance, not only of the configuration.
- You are preparing a certification (ISO 27001, SOC 2) with an accredited auditor.
- You want an application penetration test performed by a human.
- Your multi-account architecture requires interviews to understand flows and exceptions.

## When Prowler is enough

- Your teams are comfortable with the command line and want repeated checks, for instance in a CI/CD pipeline.
- Your need is limited to security and compliance.
- You have time to analyse the results, prioritise them and write the debrief yourselves.

## Why keep Security Hub

- Security Hub monitors continuously; an audit is a one-off. The two complement each other.
- When Security Hub is enabled, the Silamir audit reuses its FSBP and CIS results, deduplicates and prioritises them.
- Security Hub covers neither costs nor resilience, and produces no deliverables for management.

## When to choose the Silamir automated audit

- You want a full review before a board meeting, a migration, an external audit or an acquisition.
- You need dated evidence for your risk management framework (DORA, internal audit).
- You want to cut the AWS bill and fix security with a single action plan.
- You want a fast starting point before focusing a manual audit on the topics that deserve it.

## When the Silamir audit is not the right choice

- You are looking for continuous monitoring: an audit is a snapshot at a given date, Security Hub and GuardDuty monitor all the time.
- You want to cover dozens of accounts of an organisation at once: each audit covers one AWS account.
- You are preparing a certification or want a human penetration test: you need an auditor or a pentester.
- Your reports must be in English: deliverables are currently written in French.
- Your infrastructure runs on Azure or Google Cloud: the audit covers AWS only.

## Choosing an AWS audit: frequently asked questions

**Can these approaches be combined?**

Yes, and that is often the most effective: Security Hub for continuous monitoring, the automated audit for a full, prioritised review, and a manual audit or penetration test on the topics that need human expertise.

**Does the Silamir audit use Prowler?**

No. Collection relies on read-only AWS CLI scripts and, when available, on Security Hub results. The analysis is done by Anthropic Claude models through Amazon Bedrock.

**Can AI replace an auditor?**

Not entirely. The AI analyses the collected configuration and writes the reports; each finding names the affected resource. It does not replace an expert's judgement on your organisation or business context.

**What about AWS Audit Manager?**

AWS Audit Manager is in maintenance mode and has accepted no new customers since April 30, 2026. Our [AWS Audit Manager alternative](https://audit.aws.silamir.com/en/aws-audit-manager-alternative) page explains what to use instead, depending on your need.

**Do I need to pay for Security Hub to use the audit?**

No. Security Hub is not required: without it, the audit relies on direct collection of the configuration. When it is enabled, its results enrich the report.

## Guides on this topic

- **[How to audit an AWS account](https://audit.aws.silamir.com/en/resources/how-to-audit-aws-account)**: Audit an AWS account in 7 steps: scope, read-only access, inventory, CIS v5.0 and FSBP baseline, costs, prioritization. Native tools and options compared.
- **[AWS audit in a single night](https://audit.aws.silamir.com/en/resources/aws-audit-in-a-single-night-ai)**: Read-only access, ten domains analysed in parallel, attack paths and FinOps: how AI is reinventing the AWS security and FinOps audit.
- **[Well-Architected review cost](https://audit.aws.silamir.com/en/resources/aws-well-architected-review-cost)**: The Well-Architected Tool is free: a review costs time, in-house or with a partner. Options compared, AWS funding and what an automated audit adds.

## The audit for your need

- **[AWS security audit](https://audit.aws.silamir.com/en/aws-security-audit)**: Automated AWS security assessment against CIS AWS Foundations v5.0 and FSBP: a score per standard, attack paths and a prioritized remediation plan. USD 299.
- **[AWS FinOps audit](https://audit.aws.silamir.com/en/aws-finops-audit)**: AWS cost optimization audit: Savings Plans, rightsizing, unused resources, VPC endpoints. Each saving is priced per month, with the CLI commands to apply it.
- **[DORA and AWS](https://audit.aws.silamir.com/en/dora-aws)**: DORA and AWS: AWS is a critical provider, your account configuration is still yours. Audit of access, encryption, logging and backups, with data kept in Paris.

## Ready to audit your AWS account?

Subscribe on AWS Marketplace, deploy the read-only role and get your reports within the hour.

[Subscribe on AWS Marketplace](https://aws.amazon.com/marketplace/pp/prodview-llvpm5sa4mljs) · [See how it works](https://audit.aws.silamir.com/en/how-it-works)
